How to Choose Dental Chews for a Small Dog: Seal, Size, Softness
Heads up: we earn a commission when you buy through some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend. How we make money.
We earn a commission from links on this page, at no cost to you.
This guide is based on research checked against the sources listed. It’s based on research, not hands-on use.
If we could tape one rule to every chew shelf, it would be this: press your thumbnail into the chew, and if it doesn’t dent, put it back. Zoetis says most veterinary dentists recommend that test, and the chews that fail it are the ones the sources blame for broken teeth. If your dog is choking or has swallowed a large piece, call your vet or an emergency clinic now.
The short answer: choose a chew that has the VOHC seal, comes in the size made for your dog’s weight and is soft enough to dent with your thumbnail. Count it as part of the day’s treats, stay with your dog while they chew, and keep brushing. Skip antlers, bones, hooves, yak chews and hard nylon for a small dog.
Sorting the worry:
- Fine to watch at home: your dog chews, eats and plays as usual and shows no change after a chew.
- Call your vet today: after chewing something hard, your dog licks their lips, grinds their teeth or turns down a soft treat they normally take. Also call if you can see a broken or cracked tooth.
- Call your vet or an emergency clinic now: choking, a large piece swallowed, or vomiting after a chew, especially with no stool or with listlessness.
Why are small dogs more likely to need help with their teeth?
Because extra-small breeds were up to 5 times more likely than giant breeds to be diagnosed with gum disease in one large study.
Waltham, a pet research center, reported a study of medical records from more than 3 million US pets. Extra-small breeds (under 6.5 kg / 14.3 lb) were up to five times more likely to be diagnosed with periodontal (gum) disease than giant breeds (over 25 kg / 55 lb). That compares only those two groups, not every small dog with every large one. Worth knowing too: Waltham is owned by Mars, which also makes Greenies, a chew on the VOHC list dated November 14, 2025.
The Royal Canin Academy gives three reasons small dogs are prone to it:
- Their teeth are crowded into a small jaw.
- They tend to chew less than large dogs.
- Owners find it harder to brush such small mouths.
None of this means you’ve done something wrong. A small mouth just needs more help, and the help shouldn’t crack a tooth on the way in.
What does the VOHC seal on a dental chew actually mean?
The seal means the chew has evidence behind its claim. PetMD explains that the maker has to run two sets of clinical trials and show at least a 20% reduction in plaque, tartar or both.
The Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC) awards the seal for two separate claims, and each needs its own data:
- “Helps Control Plaque”: plaque is the soft film that builds up on teeth.
- “Helps Control Tartar”: tartar is plaque that has hardened.
The pack tells you which claim the chew has. Some have one, some both.
This is where people trust the seal too far:
- It isn’t a safety rating. Nothing we found says VOHC checks whether a chew is safe to swallow or hard on teeth. A sealed chew still has to get past your thumbnail.
- Small breeds may not be covered. None of the sources we read say whether the trials included toy breeds, or whether each size of a product was tested separately.
To check a product, look it up on VOHC’s list of accepted dog products at vohc.org. The PDF version is dated November 14, 2025. Several listings say “four sizes” or “all sizes,” so make sure a size for your dog’s weight is included.
How do I check a dental chew in the shop aisle?
Check four things in this order: seal, size, softness, calories. Fail one, and it goes back on the shelf.
Sam stood in the chew aisle with his phone in one hand and a pale, rock-hard chew in the other, the kind sold on how long it lasts. Biscuit was at home, still new to the house and keen on anything he could carry. Sam pressed his thumbnail into the chew, hard, and left no mark at all. He put it back and picked up one that gave a little under his nail, which looked less impressive and was exactly the point.
- Seal. Look for the VOHC seal and read which claim it has (plaque, tartar or both).
- Size. Buy the size the pack lists for your dog’s weight. Zoetis advises choosing the correct size for your dog. The WSAVA (a global vets’ association) says any treat should be a suitable size and shape to lower the risk of choking.
- Softness. Use the thumbnail test, which Zoetis’s page on broken teeth describes: if your fingernail can dent the chew, it’s soft enough. A vet’s Q&A column (October 2025) suggests a second check, the “kneecap test”: if the chew hurts when you knock it against your kneecap, it’s too hard for teeth.
- Calories. Find the calories per chew on the pack. If they aren’t listed, WSAVA’s treat guide suggests contacting the maker.
Which chews should a small dog skip?
Skip anything that fails the thumbnail test, and be careful with chews that get small enough to swallow whole. Each row names its source in the last column.
| Chew type | Thumbnail test | Main risk | Who says so |
|---|---|---|---|
| VOHC-accepted dental chew, correct size | Check each product | Calories; choking if the size is too small for the dog | WSAVA |
| Antlers | Fails | Broken teeth | Zoetis, WSAVA, vet column |
| Natural bones (cooked or raw) | Fails | Broken teeth; WSAVA calls bones very dangerous | Zoetis, WSAVA, vet column |
| Hooves | Fails | Broken teeth | Zoetis, WSAVA, vet column |
| Yak chews | Fails | Broken teeth | Zoetis |
| Hard nylon toys | Fails the kneecap test | Broken teeth | Vet column |
| Bully sticks | Not covered by sources | Choking as the stick gets smaller | Preventive Vet |
| Ice cubes | Fails the kneecap test | Broken teeth | Vet column |
Read down the second column. Antlers, bones, hooves, yak: fails, fails, fails, fails.
The thumbnail decides.
We’ll grant the other side its point: very hard chews last longer, which is why people buy them. The sources above blame that same hardness for broken teeth. Softer chews get used up faster and add calories. For a small dog, we’d count the calories and skip the hard chews.
Any chew can be a problem if a piece breaks off. Preventive Vet notes that pieces can get stuck in the windpipe, stomach or intestines. Stay with your dog while they chew, and take the chew away once it’s small enough to swallow whole.
How many dental chews a day is right for a small dog?
Check the pack and your vet: for some small dogs, even one chew is a lot. The WSAVA’s treat guide for dogs (November 2025) says treats should always make up less than 10% of a dog’s daily calories, and it counts chews as treats.
A small dog’s daily calories are low, so one chew can eat much of that 10%. A WSAVA treat sheet from 2024 notes that for some dogs, just one common chew could go over the daily treat limit.
What to do:
- Ask your vet how many calories your dog needs a day. A tenth of that is the most treats should add up to, not a target.
- Compare that with the calories per chew on the pack.
- On days your dog has a chew, cut back on other treats.
- Follow the feeding guide on the pack, and let your vet decide whether your dog can have more.
Can a dental chew replace brushing?
No. A chew helps between brushings, but it doesn’t replace brushing or cleanings at the vet.
The American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA) calls brushing with a soft-bristled brush the gold standard. Its 2013 guidelines say dental chews and diets can be used until an owner is comfortable brushing. Its 2019 guidelines add three points:
- Brushing removes plaque but not hardened tartar.
- Brushing needs to be daily to help.
- Even daily brushing doesn’t remove the need for professional cleanings under anesthesia.
If brushing a tiny mouth feels impossible right now, AAHA’s 2013 guidelines treat a chew as a reasonable bridge while you build up to it. Ask your vet to show you how to start.
When should I call the vet after a chew?
Call if your dog shows any of the signs below. Zoetis notes that many dogs show no pain even with a broken tooth, so look in the mouth after a hard chew.
Call your vet if:
- After chewing something hard, your dog licks their lips, grinds their teeth or turns down a soft treat they normally take.
- You can see a broken or cracked tooth. Zoetis says to have your dog seen right away.
Call your vet or an emergency clinic now if:
- Your dog is choking, or you saw them swallow a large piece of a chew.
- Your dog is vomiting, especially with no stool, or seems listless after eating a chew. PetMD lists these as signs of an intestinal blockage, which needs immediate veterinary care.
This guide is general information, not veterinary advice. Your vet knows your dog’s mouth and weight, and can tell you which chew and how many suit them.
At the next checkup, ask your vet to show you how to brush. Until then, the thumbnail decides.
Questions people ask
What is the safest dental chew for a small dog?
Choose a chew with the VOHC seal, in the size listed for your dog's weight, that you can dent with your thumbnail. The VOHC seal shows evidence of reducing plaque or tartar, but it isn't a safety rating. Stay with your dog while they chew, and take the chew away once it's small enough to swallow whole.
Does the VOHC seal mean a dog chew is safe?
No. The seal means the maker's two sets of clinical trials showed at least a 20% reduction in plaque, tartar or both. Nothing found in this research says VOHC checks safety. You still need to check the size, softness and calories yourself.
Are antlers and bones OK for small dogs?
Vets advise against them. Zoetis says antlers, bones, hooves and yak chews fail the thumbnail test. WSAVA advises avoiding very hard chews such as antlers and hooves, and calls cooked and raw bones very dangerous. The main risk is broken teeth.
How many dental chews can my small dog have a day?
Follow the feeding guide on the pack and ask your vet. WSAVA's November 2025 treat guide says treats, including chews, should make up less than 10% of a dog's daily calories, and its 2024 sheet notes that for some dogs one common chew can go over that limit.
Can dental chews replace brushing my dog's teeth?
No. AAHA calls brushing with a soft-bristled brush the gold standard and says chews can help until you're comfortable brushing. Brushing needs to be daily to help. Neither brushing nor chews remove the need for professional cleanings under anesthesia.
Sources
- Waltham: Small dog breeds at highest risk of dental disease
- PetMD: What is VOHC and what does it do?
- Royal Canin Academy: A short guide to dental disease in small-breed dogs
- VOHC FAQs
- VOHC Accepted Products
- VOHC Accepted Products Table, Dogs (11-14-25)
- Zoetis Petcare: Fractured and broken teeth in dogs
- News Tribune: Antlers, other hard chews break dogs' teeth (Oct 2025)
- Preventive Vet: Potential dangers of popular dog chews
- WSAVA: Feeding treats to your dog (November 2025)
- WSAVA: Feeding treats to your dog (2024)
- PetMD: Dog intestinal blockage, signs and what to do
- AAHA Dental Care Guidelines (2013)
- AAHA Dental Care Guidelines (2019)
Drafted with AI assistance from our research notes and reviewed by a person before publishing. We research and curate; we don't run hands-on tests. Not veterinary advice: for symptoms, dosing or diagnosis, talk to your vet.